Ray Hoskins

Essays

Hard Work Was Never the Mistake

Marcus lives in Detroit. He is a veteran. He has always believed that you work hard, you take responsibility for your life, and you do not wait around for someone to rescue you.

In Reversing the Drift, that belief is the whole foundation of who he is. Then he watched both political parties fail to keep faith with people like him. He felt betrayed by both. And into that gap stepped a message of self-reliance, loud and sure of itself.

I want to be careful here. Nothing about Marcus's values was foolish. Hard work and personal responsibility are good things. If you carry them, you are in good company.

So why would a person like that end up defending something that did not serve him?

Psychologists have a name for part of the answer. They call it system justification. John Jost and Mahzarin Banaji described it in 1994. The idea is simple and a little unsettling. Human beings are motivated to see the arrangements they live inside as fair, legitimate, and reasonable. We do this even when the arrangement is costing us.

Here is the part that surprised me. As far as the research shows, the pull tends to get stronger when we feel dependent on a system and cannot easily change it. If you cannot leave, the mind helps you stay. It does this by quietly editing the story until the situation feels acceptable.

I studied sociology and trained to teach it, and one thing stuck with me. People rarely experience a system as a system. They experience it as the way things are. That makes it very hard to question, because questioning it feels like questioning the ground under your feet.

In my twenty-five years in addictions work, I saw a close cousin of this again and again. People defend what they depend on. They are not stupid. They are protecting something that keeps them upright.

Now put Marcus back in the picture. When both parties let him down, he had two choices. He could face the painful idea that the order he trusted had not been fair to him. Or he could find a new story that explained everything and gave him back his footing. A message of self-reliance offered the second path. It spoke straight to the needs the book names: to feel capable and to feel influential.

The drift did not start with hatred. It started with a real value and a real hurt, and someone who knew how to speak to both.

That is why the book never shames him. "If it happened to you, you're not stupid. You're human."

Here is what I would offer anyone who sees themselves in Marcus. Keep the value. Hard work was never the mistake. Responsibility is still worth building a life on. What you can do is ask a quieter question: who benefits when my best value is used to keep me from asking questions?

Curiosity is a quiet act of courage. You do not have to give up who you are to ask it.

If any of this sounds like someone you know, or like you, I wrote the book for exactly that.

Read the first chapter of Reversing the Drift free

Or get the book on Amazon

Want more like this?

Get the first chapter of one of my books free, plus new essays now and then.

Get a free chapter